Benny Peiser / 01.11.2011 / 22:34 / 0 / Seite ausdrucken

Revenge of the Sovereign Nation

Greece’s astonishing decision to call a referendum – “a supreme act of democracy and of patriotism”, in the words of premier George Papandreou – has more or less killed last week’s EU summit deal.

The markets cannot wait three months to find out the result, and nor is China going to lend much money to the EFSF bail-out fund until this is cleared up. The whole edifice is already at risk of crumbling. Société Générale is down 15pc this morning. The FTSE MIB index in Milan has crashed 7pc. Italian bond spreads have jumped to 450 basis points.

Unless the European Central Bank step in very soon and on a massive scale to shore up Italy, the game is up. We will have a spectacular smash-up.

If handled badly, the disorderly insolvency of the world’s third largest debtor with €1.9 trillion in public debt and nearer €3.5 trillion in total debt would be a much greater event than the fall of Credit Anstalt in 1931. (Let me add that Italy is not fundamentally insolvent. It is only in these straits because it does not have a lender of last resort, a sovereign central bank, or a sovereign currency. The euro structure itself has turned a solvent state into an insolvent state. It is reverse alchemy.)

The Anstalt debacle triggered the European banking collapse, set off tremors in London and New York, and turned recession into depression. Within four months the global financial order had essentially disintegrated. That is the risk right now as the reality of Europe’s make-up becomes clear.

The Greek referendum – if it is not overtaken by a collapse of the government first – has left officials in Paris, Berlin, and Brussels speechless with rage. The ingratitude of them. The spokesman of French president Nicolas Sarkozy (himself half Greek, from Thessaloniki) said the move was “irrational and dangerous”. Rainer Brüderle, Bundestag leader of the Free Democrats, said the Greeks appear to be “wriggling out” of a solemn commitment. They face outright bankruptcy, he blustered.

Well yes, but at least the Greeks are stripping away the self-serving claims of the creditor states that their “rescue” loan packages are to “save Greece”. They are nothing of the sort. Greece has been subjected to the greatest fiscal squeeze ever attempted in a modern industrial state, without any offsetting monetary stimulus or devaluation. The economy has so far collapsed by 14pc to 16pc since the peak – depending who you ask – and is spiralling downwards at a vertiginous pace.

The debt has exploded under the EU-IMF Troika programme. It is heading for 180pc of GDP by next year. Even under the haircut deal, Greek debt will be 120pc of GDP in 2020 after nine years of depression. That is not cure, it is a punitive sentence. Every major claim by the inspectors at the outset of the Memorandum has turned out to be untrue. The facts are so far from the truth that it is hard to believe they ever thought it could work. The Greeks were made to suffer IMF austerity without the usual IMF cure. This was done for one purpose only, to buy time for banks and other Club Med states to beef up their defences.

It was not an unreasonable strategy (though a BIG LIE), and might not have failed entirely if the global economy recovered briskly this year and if the ECB had behaved with an ounce of common sense. Instead the ECB choose to tighten.

When the history books are written, I think scholarship will be very harsh on the handful of men running EMU monetary policy over the last three to four years. They are not as bad as the Chicago Fed of 1930 to 1932, but not much better. So no, like the Spartans, Thebans, and Thespians at the Pass of Thermopylae, the Greeks were sacrificed to buy time for the alliance.

The referendum is a healthy reminder that Europe is a collection of sovereign democracies, tied by treaty law for certain arrangements. It is a union only in name.

Certain architects of EMU calculated that the single currency would itself become the catalyst for a quantum leap in integration that could not be achieved otherwise.

They were warned by the European Commission’s own economists and by the Bundesbank that the undertaking was unworkable without fiscal union, and probably catastrophic if extended to Southern Europe. Yet the ideological view was that any trauma would be a “beneficial crisis”, to be exploited to advance the Project.

This was the Monnet Method of fait accompli and facts on the ground. These great manipulators of Europe’s destiny may yet succeed, but so far the crisis is not been remotely beneficial.
The sovereign nation of Germany has blocked every move to fiscal union, whether Eurobonds, debt-pooling, fiscal transfers, or shared budgets. It has blocked use of the ECB as a genuine central bank. The great Verfassungsgericht has more or less declared the outcome desired by those early EMU conspirators to be illegal and off limits.

And as my old friend Gideon Rachman at the FT writes this morning: the Greek vote is “a hammer blow aimed at the most sensitive spot of the whole European construction – its lacks of popular support and legitimacy.”

Indeed, how many times did we chew this over in the restaurants of Brussels, Stockholm, Copenhagen, Dublin, or the Hague years ago, as one NO followed another every time an EU state dared to hold a referendum.

I think it is fair to say events are unfolding more or less as we expected.

Sie lesen gern Achgut.com?
Zeigen Sie Ihre Wertschätzung!

via Paypal via Direktüberweisung
Leserpost

netiquette:

Leserbrief schreiben

Leserbriefe können nur am Erscheinungstag des Artikel eingereicht werden. Die Zahl der veröffentlichten Leserzuschriften ist auf 50 pro Artikel begrenzt. An Wochenenden kann es zu Verzögerungen beim Erscheinen von Leserbriefen kommen. Wir bitten um Ihr Verständnis.

Verwandte Themen
Benny Peiser / 28.01.2017 / 10:49 / 0

Wie die Energiewende die deutsche Umweltbewegung spaltet

Professor Fritz Vahrenholt zählt zum Urgestein der deutschen Umweltbewegung und gilt als einer der frühen Protagonisten von sogenannten erneuerbaren Energien in Deutschland. Inzwischen ist er…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 28.08.2015 / 15:21 / 0

Sonnenfinsternis in Großbritannien: Regierung streicht Solarförderung um 90%

Britain’s solar boom is over after ministers announced they would offer virtually no subsidies for people to install panels on their homes. In a surprise…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 14.08.2015 / 13:24 / 0

Vom Winde verweht

Gone with the wind?  The impact of wind turbines on tourism demand in Germany While wind energy production is relatively free from environmental externalities such…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 08.06.2015 / 23:04 / 2

G7: Mythos und Wirklichkeit

Mythos: Die „Klimakanzlerin“ Merkel blieb beharrlich: Die G 7 haben auf Schloss Elmau angekündigt, dass die Industriestaaten in Zukunft komplett auf Kohle, Öl und Gas…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 05.06.2015 / 15:35 / 1

Hendricks fordert Schluss mit Kohle, Öl und Gas

Die Grünen haben vor zwei Jahren einen Energiefahrplan zu Umsetzung der Energiewende vorgelegt. Die Bundesregierung ist offenbar bereit, ihn umzusetzen. Nach dem Atomausstieg fordert die…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 27.05.2015 / 22:32 / 0

Energiewende erreicht erstes Ziel

Die deutsche Wettbewerbsfähigkeit lässt nach. Im aktuellen “World Competitiveness Ranking” rutscht Deutschland weltweit ans Ende der Top 10… Auch beim weltweiten Infrastrukturvergleich steht Deutschland diesmal…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 18.05.2015 / 18:33 / 0

Britisches Gesetz gegen die (onshore) Windkraft

Local residents will be able to block all future onshore wind farms under new measures to be fast-tracked into law, the new energy secretary has…/ mehr

Benny Peiser / 21.02.2015 / 15:37 / 0

Weltenergierat warnt: Deutsche Energiewende gefährdet Stromversorgungssicherheit Europas

Internationale Experten hegen große Zweifel am Erfolg der deutschen Energiewende. Zu diesem Ergebnis kommt eine Umfrage des Weltenergierats, aus der das Nachrichtenmagazin FOCUS exklusiv berichtet.…/ mehr

Unsere Liste der Guten

Ob als Klimaleugner, Klugscheißer oder Betonköpfe tituliert, die Autoren der Achse des Guten lassen sich nicht darin beirren, mit unabhängigem Denken dem Mainstream der Angepassten etwas entgegenzusetzen. Wer macht mit? Hier
Autoren

Unerhört!

Warum senken so viele Menschen die Stimme, wenn sie ihre Meinung sagen? Wo darf in unserer bunten Republik noch bunt gedacht werden? Hier
Achgut.com