Auf den englischsprachigen Seiten von Spiegel Online, hat Uwe Buse eine bemerkenswert weitsichtige und ausgewogene Analyse der Emotionalisierung und Politisierung des UN Klimarats (IPCC) veröffentlicht.

Money quote: “No matter where one encounters officials from the IPCC—at the organization’s headquarters in Geneva, in Brussels during the negotiations over the SPM or in Potsdam, where the German authors, together with the Federal Ministry of the Environment, are staging a workshop on the world climate report—everyone seems to be talking more like environmental activists than scientists these days.

The problem is that the IPCC is not a political group whose goal is to exert pressure, but a scientific institution and panel of experts. Its members ought to present their results and analyses dispassionately, the way pathologists or psychiatrists do when serving as expert witnesses in court, no matter how horrible the victim’s injuries and how deviant the perpetrator’s psyche are.

Peter Weingart, a sociologist of science from Bielefeld believes that the climate experts’ lack of distance has something to do with their training. Scientists usually learn only to reflect on the results of their work, not on their role within the social decision-making process. As a result, they join forces with politicians who share their views. And in this way they do harm to science.” http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,480766,00.html